Water: real-world examples
Named cases you can use in an answer, each under the syllabus point it illustrates and linked to the lesson it comes from.
4 Water
4.1.1Movements of water in the hydrosphere are driven by solar radiation and gravity.
Mer de Glace retreat, France
On the Mer de Glace glacier in the French Alps, solar radiation drives summer meltwater into the Arve and Rhône and winter sublimation off the ice, while gravity drives the ice downhill at ~75 m/year; since 1850 it has retreated ~2.5 km and thinned ~200 m, forcing repeated relocation of access from the 1909 Montenvers station.
Shows both drivers of the hydrosphere at one site (solar-driven melting and sublimation versus gravity-driven ice and meltwater flow), with outputs now exceeding inputs.
4.1.5Human activities, such as agriculture, deforestation and urbanization, can alter these flows and stores.
Lake Urmia shrinkage, Iran
Intensive irrigated agriculture (sugar beet, apples, wheat, grapes) in the catchment of Lake Urmia, north-western Iran, involving over 50 dams and more than 88,000 wells, cut river streamflow and depleted groundwater so severely that by 2015 the lake had lost about 88% of its surface area and 95% of its volume, leaving a 5,000 km² salt desert whose dust storms harm about 6 million people.
Demonstrates how agricultural diversion of inflows and groundwater abstraction shrinks a surface freshwater store and reduces streamflow and groundwater flows.
Valencia DANA floods, Spain
During the Valencia DANA of 29 October 2024, over 490 mm of rain fell in 8 hours onto a heavily sealed and deforested floodplain, so infiltration dropped near zero and run-off surged; the barranco del Poyo rose to a peak discharge of ~2,300 m³/s in under two hours, producing flash floods that killed over 230 people, Spain's deadliest in modern history.
Shows how urbanisation reduces infiltration and evapotranspiration while increasing surface run-off, converting rainfall into a rapid, deadly flood peak.
4.1.6The steady state of any water body can be demonstrated through flow diagrams of inputs and outputs.
Lake Geneva water balance, Switzerland-France
Lake Geneva (Lac Léman) holds ~89 km³ of freshwater and stays roughly in steady state with annual inputs and outputs both around 7.1 km³/year (Rhône inflow 5.7, outflow 6.6, evaporation 0.4, abstraction 0.1), supplying drinking water to about 1 million people.
Quantifies steady state as balanced inputs and outputs in a real water budget, letting sustainable abstraction limits be calculated.
Lake Geneva Water SystemsSalar de Atacama aquifer, Chile
The freshwater aquifer beside the Salar de Atacama in northern Chile receives ~180 million m³/year of Andean recharge against outputs of ~165 million m³/year (120 seepage to flamingo wetlands and Atacameño farms, 30 evaporation, 15 town abstraction), so a lithium mining request for an extra 40 million m³/year would push outputs above inputs and deplete the store.
Shows how a flow diagram of inputs and outputs sets the maximum sustainable harvest and reveals when abstraction breaches steady state.
Salar de Atacama, Chile Water Systems
4.1.7Water has unique physical and chemical properties that support and sustain life.HL
Lake Geneva deoxygenation, Switzerland
Lake Geneva (309 m deep) has not mixed completely since winter 2011/12: in 2024/25 the surface only cooled to 7.8 °C (1.5 °C above the 1991–2020 average), so mixing reached just 110 m. As a result, dissolved oxygen at 300–309 m fell from 8.4 to 2.4 mg/L between 2012 and 2025 (CIPEL data).
Shows how temperature-dependent density sets up thermal stratification that wind cannot break, and traces the knock-on effect on gas supply to deep water as the climate warms.
Lavaux vineyards and lake climate, Switzerland
The Lavaux vineyards sit on terraced slopes above Lake Geneva. The lake's high specific heat capacity keeps local temperatures mild and stable, which helps the grapes ripen.
Demonstrates how water's high specific heat capacity moderates the climate of the land around a large water body.
Lavaux, Vaud, Switzerland Properties of Water and Carbon Sink
4.1.8The oceans act as a carbon sink by absorbing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequestering it.HL
StudyOcean CO₂ absorption, Global Carbon Budget
According to the Global Carbon Budget 2025, the ocean absorbed about 29% of human CO₂ emissions over the past decade, even as atmospheric CO₂ reached about 425.6 ppm. Over 2015–2024, however, the ocean sink was about 7% smaller than it would have been without climate change.
Quantifies how much the sink has moderated the rise in atmospheric CO₂, and gives measured evidence that warming is already weakening it as it moves towards saturation.
2015–2024 Properties of Water and Carbon Sink
4.1.9Carbon sequestered in oceans over the short term as dissolved carbon dioxide causes ocean acidification; over the longer term, carbon is taken up into living organisms as biomass that accumulates on the seabed.HL
StatisticOcean acidification since the industrial era
Since the industrial era began, surface ocean pH has fallen from about 8.2 to about 8.1, roughly a 30% rise in hydrogen ion concentration. This reduces the carbonate ions that corals, molluscs and plankton need to build calcium carbonate shells and skeletons.
Quantifies the short-term acidification pathway and links the logarithmic pH change to its biological consequence for organisms that calcify.
4.1.10The temperature of water varies with depth, with cold water below and warmer water above. Differences in density restrict mixing between the layers, leading to persistent stratification.HL
Lac de Joux ice safety decline
Lac de Joux in the Vallée de Joux, Vaud, is the largest lake in the Jura that freezes over, because fresh water below 4 °C floats and freezes at the surface. Safe ice is becoming rarer: skating was not possible for three years before January 2022, and in February 2026 only a few marked sections were open.
Shows that fresh water's 4 °C density maximum makes lakes freeze from the top down, and how warming is undermining this.
4.1.12Global warming and salinity changes have increased the intensity of ocean stratification.HL
StudyOcean stratification increase, top 2,000 m
Li et al. (2020) found that stratification in the top 2,000 m of the ocean increased by about 5.3% between 1960 and 2018. Around 71% of the rise was in the top 200 m, and over 90% of it came from warming.
Quantifies the intensification of stratification and shows that it is concentrated near the surface and driven mainly by temperature.
1960–2018 Stratification and Ocean CirculationSouthern Ocean surface freshening and stratification
The Southern Ocean surface freshened from the 1980s as ice melted, which strengthened stratification. Since 2015, surface salinity has risen and stratification has weakened, sea ice has hit record lows and the Maud Rise polynya in the Weddell Sea has reopened (Silvano et al., 2025).
Demonstrates how salinity changes control the strength of stratification in both directions, and the need for ongoing monitoring.
4.1.13Upwellings in oceans and freshwater bodies can bring cold, nutrient-rich waters to the surface.HL
Peru anchovy fishing season cancellation
Off Peru, trade winds drive upwelling of cold, nutrient-rich water that supports the anchoveta fishery. During the 2023 El Niño, weaker winds strengthened stratification and suppressed upwelling, so Peru cancelled its June 2023 anchovy fishing season.
Links upwelling directly to productivity and shows how ENSO switches it on and off, with economic consequences.
Upwelling event, Lake Geneva
On 28 June to 1 July 2017, a days-long south-westerly wind along Lake Geneva pushed the warm surface layer north-east, and cold deep water upwelled at the Bains des Pâquis, Geneva, dropping the water from 23 °C to 8 °C in 48 hours while Montreux and Évian stayed at about 22 °C.
Shows that wind-driven upwelling also happens in freshwater bodies, and that a thin early-summer mixed layer is easily displaced.
4.1.14Thermohaline circulation systems are driven by differences in temperature and salinity. The resulting differences in water density drives the ocean conveyor belt, which distributes heat around the world and thus affects climate.HL
StudyDeep AMOC flow decline, western North Atlantic
A study published in April 2026 used seafloor instruments at four sites along the western North Atlantic (about 16.5°N to 42.5°N). All four recorded the same decline in deep AMOC flow over nearly two decades, but records only began in the early 2000s.
Gives evidence that freshening may be weakening the conveyor belt, while showing why short records make the trend uncertain.
4.2.1Water security is having access to sufficient amounts of safe drinking water.
Switzerland vs UAE water security
Switzerland gets ~1,200 mm of rain a year and the UAE only ~100 mm. Yet both are wealthy (GDP per capita ~US$95,000 and ~US$50,000) and have almost universal safely managed drinking water (100% and 99%). In Niger (~US$600 GDP per capita), only ~14% of people have it.
Demonstrates that water security depends on the money and infrastructure to store, treat and deliver water rather than on rainfall alone.
2022–23 Water Security and Scarcity
4.2.2Social, cultural, economic and political factors all have an impact on the availability of, and equitable access to, the freshwater required for human well-being.
Cape Town drought, South Africa
During Cape Town's 2015–2018 drought, dam levels fell to ~23% of capacity and authorities imposed a 50 L/person/day limit and rising block tariffs; wealthy suburbs drilled private boreholes while ~20% of residents in informal settlements shared communal taps, and agricultural water rights were cut by 60% amid rivalry between city and national government and the legacy of apartheid-era infrastructure.
Demonstrates how social, cultural, economic and political factors together produced deeply unequal water access within one city.
4.2.4Water supplies can be increased by constructing dams, reservoirs, rainwater catchment systems, desalination plants and enhancement of natural wetlands.
Dar Si Hmad fog harvesting, Morocco
In Morocco's semi-arid Aït Baamrane region, the NGO Dar Si Hmad runs the world's largest fog-harvesting project, with ~1,700 m² of mesh nets on Mount Boutmezguida collecting on average ~35,000 litres per day and piping water to over 1,000 people across ~16 villages, cutting women's daily water-collection time from around 3 hours.
Shows a low-energy rainwater/fog catchment system delivering village-scale supply where fog is reliable but not at city scale.
Aït Baamrane, Morocco Water Security and ScarcityGrand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, Ethiopia
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile, inaugurated in 2025 with a ~74 km³ reservoir and ~5,150 MW capacity (costing ~US$5 billion), more than doubles Ethiopia's electricity but is fiercely opposed by Egypt, which draws ~97% of its freshwater from the Nile, and displaced 5,000–20,000 people.
Shows how dams and reservoirs increase supply while creating evaporation losses, displacement and international disputes.
4.2.5Water scarcity refers to the limited availability of water to human societies.
Haiti drinking water and sanitation gap
Haiti receives around 1,400 mm of rain a year yet roughly 70% of its population lacks safely managed drinking water and two-thirds lack basic sanitation, because political instability and disasters such as the 2010 earthquake left treatment plants, pipes and sewage systems under-built.
Shows economic water scarcity, where abundant rainfall exists but weak infrastructure and governance prevent safe delivery.
Jordan water scarcity
Jordan is one of the most water-scarce countries on Earth: in 2021 each Jordanian had only ~61 m³ of renewable freshwater per year (against the 500 m³ absolute-scarcity threshold), its Jordan and Yarmouk river flows are shared with Syria and Israel, and about half of households receive piped water only once a week despite near-universal connection.
Demonstrates physical water scarcity where extensive infrastructure cannot compensate for a genuine climatic and geographic lack of water.
4.2.6Water conservation techniques can be applied at a domestic level.
BASIX rainwater tanks, NSW
Under NSW's BASIX scheme all new Australian homes since 2004 must meet water-saving targets, usually via rainwater tanks, and ~26% of Australian households now have a tank (rising to ~50% in Adelaide).
Shows regulation-led domestic rainwater harvesting scaled through building codes.
Chennai Day Zero
Chennai's "Day Zero" arrived in June 2019 when all four city reservoirs ran dry and families queued for 25 L of water per day, prompting mandatory dual plumbing for grey-water reuse in many new buildings.
Illustrates rationing and grey-water recycling as domestic conservation responses forced by acute urban scarcity.
4.2.7Water conservation strategies can be applied at an industrial level in food production systems.
India International Year of Millets
India championed the 2023 UN International Year of Millets, expanding drought-resistant crops such as pearl millet, ragi and sorghum (viable on ~350 mm rainfall/year versus ~1,200 mm for rice) to 13.7 million ha by 2024, and highlighting that 1 kg of beef needs ~15,000 L of water against ~1,800 L for wheat.
Shows drought-resistant crops and diet as low-infrastructure industrial strategies that cut agricultural water demand.
Sundrop Farms solar greenhouse, Port Augusta
Sundrop Farms at Port Augusta, South Australia is a 20 ha greenhouse using solar-desalinated seawater to grow ~17,000 tonnes of tomatoes per year with no fresh water and no fossil fuels, built for ~A$200 million.
Demonstrates a capital-intensive greenhouse system that eliminates freshwater use in industrial food production.
Port Augusta, South Australia Water Conservation Strategies
4.2.8Mitigation strategies exist to address water scarcity.
Australia Millennium Drought response
Australia's national response to Millennium Drought scarcity combined near-universal metering with volumetric pricing, Melbourne's Stage 3a rationing (April 2007–April 2010) which nearly halved per-capita use from ~458 L/day in 1996 to 236 L/day in 2011, compulsory dual-flush toilets (all new toilets since 1993, saving ~32,000 L/household/year), and A$13 billion of Murray-Darling drip/sprinkler conversion saving ~700 GL/year by 2024.
Demonstrates how a high-income country combines domestic and industrial techniques into a coherent national mitigation strategy against drought-driven scarcity.
India water scarcity measures
India's response to physical and economic water scarcity blends traditional and regulatory measures: Tamil Nadu made rainwater harvesting compulsory for all buildings in 2003 (~5 million homes retrofitted in three years, raising Chennai's water table by up to 50%), Bengaluru's 2024 rationing banned drinking water for car washes and construction with ₹5,000 fines, and the PMKSY scheme put ~8 million ha under subsidised drip/sprinkler irrigation by 2024.
Shows a middle-income country's subsidy-led national mitigation strategy drawing on both domestic and agricultural techniques to address recurrent scarcity.
4.2.9Freshwater use is a planetary boundary, with increasing demand for limited freshwater resources causing increased water stress and the risk of abrupt and irreversible changes to the hydrological system.HL
Sacramento Valley aquifer compaction, California
During the 2020–2022 drought, heavy groundwater pumping in California's Sacramento Valley pushed the aquifer from elastic (reversible) squeezing into permanent compaction: residual subsidence reached 20 cm a year or more and part of its storage capacity was lost for good (PNAS, 2026).
Shows the abrupt, irreversible hydrological change the freshwater boundary warns of: steady pressure, then a sudden shift that well levels alone could not predict.
4.2.10Local and global governance is needed to maintain freshwater use at sustainable levels.HL
Genevese aquifer over-abstraction and recharge
Uncoordinated Franco-Swiss pumping over-abstracted the Genevese aquifer, which hit record lows by the mid-1970s. A 1978 agreement funded artificial recharge from the Arve at Vessy (8–10 million m³ a year), and a 2025 convention caps pumping at 5 million m³ for France and 12.5 million m³ for Switzerland.
Shows why transboundary groundwater needs international governance, and why agreements have to be renegotiated as population and drought pressures rise.
Pays de Gex water restrictions, Ain
In summer 2026 the Ain prefect raised the Pays de Gex from alerte (29 June) to crise (20 August), banning daytime watering of vegetable gardens, filling of private pools and washing cars at home. Breaking the rules can bring fines of up to €1,500.
Gives a local regulation that escalates in stages as water resources fall, showing local governance enforcing sustainable use during drought.
4.2.11Water footprints can serve as a measure of sustainable use by societies and can inform decision-making about water security.HL
Swiss Water Footprint study
The 2012 WWF/SDC Swiss Water Footprint study found Switzerland's footprint is about 1,500 m³ per person per year (global average 1,385 m³), with 82% external, falling on hotspot basins such as the Aral Sea and the Indus. This led the SDC to set up SuizAgua in Colombia (2009), where Nestlé, Holcim and other firms committed to cutting their water footprints.
Demonstrates how virtual water makes a water-rich nation depend on other countries' basins, and how footprint data can drive real decisions on water security.
4.2.12Citizen science is playing an increasing role in monitoring and managing water resources.HL
CrowdWater app, University of Zurich
The University of Zurich's CrowdWater app lets volunteers record stream levels against virtual staff gauges on photos. In a crowd-checking game covering 841 observations, about 70% of players agreed with the original observer, which fills gaps in Switzerland's costly official gauge network.
Demonstrates that low-cost crowdsourced water-level data, with crowd quality control, can extend monitoring to unmeasured streams.
Zurich, Switzerland Planetary Boundary and GovernanceRiver Wye volunteer nutrient testing
When volunteer nutrient tests from the River Wye in 2021 were checked against a laboratory, 66% of nitrate strip results agreed, but only 17% of phosphate strip results did, rising to 62% with a handheld phosphate meter (von Benzon et al., 2025).
Shows that the accuracy of crowdsourced water-quality data depends heavily on the method and kit chosen, which is a key limitation to weigh.
4.2.13"Water stress" like "water scarcity" is another measure of the limitation of water supply; it not only takes into account the scarcity of availability but also the water quality, environmental flows and accessibility.HL
Bangladesh drinking water access and quality
Bangladesh has over 7,000 m³ of renewable water per person thanks to the Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna, yet the 2025 MICS survey found only 39.3% of people used safely managed drinking water, about 15% of sources exceeded the WHO arsenic standard and 84.9% of household water had microbial contamination.
Demonstrates that a country can be free of scarcity yet water-stressed, because poor water quality reduces the clean, accessible supply.
4.2.14Water stress is defined as a clean, accessible water supply of less than 1,700 cubic metres per year per capita.HL
Egypt water scarcity per person
Egypt receives over 98% of its renewable water from outside its borders via the Nile; its supply of about 56.8 billion m³ a year against a need of 123 billion m³ gives only about 472–490 m³ per person (2026), far below 1,700 m³, with a growing population of 111 million.
Applies the 1,700 m³ threshold to a named society and explains why it falls below it through aridity, external dependence and population growth.
4.2.15The causes of increasing water stress may depend on the socio-economic context.HL
Egypt New Delta project, Western Desert
Egypt's New Delta project aims to irrigate 2.2 million feddans of Western Desert for export crops, fed by a 114 km artificial river carrying 3.5 billion m³ a year; groundwater depletion beneath the Western Desert has doubled since 2014.
Shows how an emerging economy's drive for export-led growth and foreign currency increases water stress.
Western Desert, Egypt Water Stress and Industrial SolutionsKabul groundwater depletion and contamination
Kabul's population has more than doubled to about 6 million in two decades; unregulated wells over-abstract aquifers by 44 million m³ a year, water tables have fallen 25–30 m, half of boreholes have dried up and up to 80% of groundwater is contaminated (Mercy Corps, 2025).
Contrasts with Egypt by showing population-driven over-abstraction and weak governance in a low-income country.
4.2.16Water stress can arise from transboundary disputes when water sources cross regional boundaries.HL
Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam dispute
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (begun 2011, inaugurated September 2025, 74 billion m³ storage) on the Blue Nile is disputed by Egypt, which relies on colonial-era 1929 and 1959 agreements that allocated nothing to Ethiopia; talks failed in 2023 and the 2024 Cooperative Framework Agreement is rejected by Egypt and Sudan.
Shows how upstream control of a transboundary river, rooted in colonial history, threatens downstream water security and quantity.
4.2.18Industrial freshwater production has negative environmental impacts that can be minimized but not usually eliminated.HL
UAE desalination and brine impacts, Wadi Ham
The UAE gets about 42% of its water from desalination; Gulf states release 55% of the world's 141.5 million m³ of daily brine, reverse osmosis uses 2.5–4 kWh per m³ powered largely by fossil fuels, and over-pumping at Wadi Ham, Fujairah, let saline water intrude 1.2–2.1 km inland.
Demonstrates multiple environmental costs of industrial water production that mitigation (diffusers, shifting to reverse osmosis at Taweelah) can reduce but not remove.
United Arab Emirates Water Stress and Industrial Solutions
4.3.2Humans consume organisms from freshwater and marine environments.
Atlantic salmon farming, Norway
The Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) is an anadromous high-trophic-level predator whose wild populations have collapsed across most of its North Atlantic range, so that most salmon eaten globally is now farmed, with Norway the world's largest producer followed by Chile, Scotland, the Faroe Islands and Canada.
Shows a globally significant food species and links its high trophic level to the energetic inefficiency of producing it as food.
Norway From plankton to plateLake Geneva perch imports
Lake Geneva perch (Perca fluviatilis), served as filets de perche, is the region's signature dish, but while the lake yields only ~400 tonnes a year, lakeside restaurants sell ~7,300 tonnes annually, the rest imported frozen (mainly from Estonia); a 2017 Swiss investigation found 6 of 20 restaurants falsely claiming imported perch were locally caught.
Demonstrates a local freshwater species consumed by humans and quantifies how demand outstrips local stocks even before global trade.
4.3.4The increasing global demand for seafood has encouraged use of unsustainable harvesting practices and overexploitation.
Dogger Bank bottom trawling ban
The Dogger Bank in the North Sea is one of the most intensively bottom-trawled seabeds in the world with largely degraded seafloor habitats; the UK banned bottom trawling across four offshore Marine Protected Areas including it in 2022, though enforcement remains a challenge.
Illustrates bottom trawling as a destructive unsustainable method and the gap between banning and enforcing.
Ghost fishing gear recovery, Baltic Sea
In the Baltic Sea WWF and Healthy Seas estimate several hundred tonnes of fishing gear are lost each year, and recovery dives off the German and Polish coasts have pulled up Soviet-era nets some still actively catching cod, demonstrating how ghost gear kills marine life for decades.
Shows ghost fishing as an unsustainable method causing prolonged mortality because synthetic gear does not biodegrade.
Baltic Sea From plankton to plate
4.3.5Overexploitation has led to the collapse of fisheries.
Monterey sardine second collapse, California
The Monterey Pacific sardine recovered through the 1990s but collapsed a second time, falling ~97% after 2006, prompting regulators to close the fishery from 2015, again because fishing had been allowed to continue too far into a known decline.
Shows that repeated overexploitation during natural declines reproduces collapse even after an apparent recovery.
Pacific sardine collapse, Monterey Bay
The Pacific sardine (Sardinops sagax) fishery off Monterey Bay, California, once the largest in the western hemisphere at ~700,000 tonnes/year in the 1930s–40s, collapsed after its 1946 peak, falling ~90% in five years (from ~234,000 to ~24,000 tonnes) because the fleet kept fishing hard through a natural, temperature-linked decline; a ban ran 1967–1986 and the stock never fully recovered.
Demonstrates how overexploitation combined with a natural downturn drives a fishery to a collapse from which the commercial stock cannot recover.
4.3.6The maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is the highest possible annual catch that can be sustained over time, so it should be used to set caps on fishing quotas.
Monterey sardine fleet and the yield–effort curve, California
The Monterey sardine fleet illustrates fishing well to the right of the MSY peak: because fleet capacity far exceeded the effort needed to fish at MSY, boats kept working while the stock was already falling, pushing catch onto the downhill side of the yield–effort curve rather than staying at the sustainable maximum.
Demonstrates the syllabus point that real fisheries often fish at far higher effort than the MSY, running the stock down.
Monterey Bay, California, USA Collapse, limits and warming waters
4.3.7Climate change and ocean acidification are having impacts on ecosystems and may cause collapse of some populations in freshwater or marine ecosystems.
Lake Geneva mixing failure and deep-water oxygen loss
Lake Geneva (Léman) has failed to mix fully since the cold winter of 2012 because milder winters leave surface water too warm to sink, and monitoring by CIPEL and EPFL shows deep-water oxygen has fallen ~90% in ten years, below the level most aquatic life needs.
Demonstrates climate warming stressing a freshwater ecosystem via reduced deep mixing and deoxygenation, disrupting the food web.
Mass coral bleaching, Great Barrier Reef, Australia
Australia's Great Barrier Reef, the world's largest reef system, has suffered repeated mass coral bleaching as ocean temperatures rise, with corals expelling their symbiotic algae and dying, threatening the thousands of species dependent on living coral.
Shows warming waters causing marine ecosystem stress and potential collapse that fishing quotas cannot address.
Great Barrier Reef, Australia Collapse, limits and warming waters
4.3.8Unsustainable exploitation of freshwater and marine ecosystems can be mitigated through policy legislation addressing the fishing industry and changes in consumer behaviour.
Sustainable seafood certification schemes
Sustainable seafood certification schemes shift consumer demand: the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) blue label certifies wild-caught fish, the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) certifies farmed fish, and the Marine Conservation Society Good Fish Guide advises shoppers, so producers gain a reason to fish and farm more sustainably even though labelling bans nothing.
Illustrates individual-level mitigation through consumer behaviour and food labelling working via demand rather than legal prohibition.
4.3.9Marine protected areas (MPAs) can be used to support aquatic food chains and maintain sustainable yields.
Lamlash Bay no-take zone, Scotland
Scotland's first no-take zone was created in Lamlash Bay, Isle of Arran, in 2008 (about 2.67 km²) after over ten years of campaigning by COAST; University of York surveys found king scallop density rose from about 6 to about 23 per 100 m² between 2010 and 2019, and legal-sized lobsters became around four times more abundant and larger than in nearby fished areas.
Quantifies how protecting one patch of sea allows adults to grow larger and denser, demonstrating the recovery mechanism behind MPAs.
South Arran Marine Protected Area, Scotland
In 2014 the ~280 km² South Arran Marine Protected Area was designated around Lamlash Bay, with scallop dredging banned from 2016; surveys show adult scallop density falls with distance from the boundary, a spillover sign the benefit reaches surrounding fished waters, while recovering seagrass, kelp and maerl now shelter juvenile fish including young cod.
Shows how a protected area seeds and supplies the wider sea via spillover and nursery habitat, maintaining sustainable yield beyond the reserve boundary.
4.3.10Aquaculture is the farming of aquatic organisms, including fish, molluscs, crustaceans and aquatic plants. The industry is expanding to increase food supplies and support economic development, but there are associated environmental impacts.
Cleaner fish for sea lice, Scotland
To control sea lice without relying only on chemicals, Scottish salmon farms have placed cleaner fish (wrasse and lumpfish) in cages since the 1990s to eat lice off the salmon, but large numbers of cleaner fish die in the cages, demand has pressured wild wrasse stocks, and in 2025 one of the biggest producers stopped using lumpfish.
Shows a named management technique (biological control) that reduces one impact while creating new problems, allowing evaluation.
Farmed salmon impacts, west coast lochs, Scotland
Scotland is the world's third largest producer of farmed Atlantic salmon (after Norway and Chile), producing around 163,000 tonnes in 2016 with a target of 300,000–400,000 tonnes by 2030; open net sea cages cause seabed dead zones from waste feed and faeces, copper anti-fouling toxicity, antibiotic and sea-lice pesticide pollution, sea lice spread to wild salmon, and escapees that cause genetic introgression in wild stocks.
Demonstrates aquaculture's role in expanding food supply and economic development alongside a full range of named environmental impacts.
4.3.11Productivity, thermal stratification, nutrient mixing and nutrient loading are interconnected in water systems.HL
Lake Geneva mixing failure and whitefish decline
Lake Geneva has not mixed all the way to the bottom since 2012, so phosphorus released from the bed stays trapped below the thermocline. Together with the invasive quagga mussel (first recorded in 2015), this is being investigated as a cause of the sharp fall in the whitefish catch since 2014.
Demonstrates how warming-driven thermal stratification stops nutrients from mixing back to the surface, limiting productivity even when nutrients are present in the deep water.
Lake Geneva phosphorus and whitefish catch
In Lake Geneva, phosphorus loading from sewage and detergents rose from under 15 µg/L before the 1960s to 89.5 µg/L in 1979. Decomposing algae then used up the oxygen on the lake bed and smothered the whitefish spawning gravel, so the catch fell to 30–50 tonnes a year (1974–84). After sewage treatment and Switzerland's 1986 phosphate detergent ban, phosphorus fell to about 16 µg/L and the catch reached a record of about 971 tonnes in 2014.
Shows that nutrient loading increases productivity only up to a point, and that beyond it eutrophication reduces fish stocks, so nutrients and fish yield are not simply related.
4.3.12Accurate assessment of fish stocks and monitoring of harvest rates are required for their conservation and sustainable use.HL
OrganisationGlobal Fishing Watch apparent fishing effort mapping
Global Fishing Watch uses vessels' satellite AIS and VMS position signals to map apparent fishing effort in hours across the world's oceans, including the heavily fished shelf seas of the north-east Atlantic.
Demonstrates a method of monitoring where and when fishing happens. Its limit is that it records effort rather than tonnes caught, so it must be paired with logbooks and landing records.
ICES mackerel stock assessment methods, north-east Atlantic
ICES assesses north-east Atlantic mackerel by combining several methods. Each year 40,000–50,000 mackerel are fitted with electronic RFID tags, which factory scanners detect automatically (a Lincoln index approach). A triennial egg survey estimates spawning stock biomass, and a summer trawl survey covers the Nordic Seas. These are checked against catch records.
Shows how combining several stock assessment methods, each with known weaknesses, reduces error in the population estimates on which quotas depend.
4.3.13There are risks in harvesting fish at the maximum sustainable yield (MSY) rate and these risks need to be managed carefully.HL
North-east Atlantic mackerel overfishing and ICES advice
North-east Atlantic mackerel has no sharing agreement covering all fishing nations, and since 2010 their combined quotas have averaged 39% above ICES advice. By 2025 the spawning stock (about 2.74 million tonnes) had fallen below the 3.07 million tonne limit, and ICES advised a roughly 70% cut for 2026. In September 2026 the estimate jumped to about 3.2 million tonnes, so ICES more than doubled its advice for 2027.
Shows both risks of MSY-based management: unilateral overshooting of advice pushes a stock towards breeding failure, and large year-to-year swings in the estimates show how uncertain the MSY is, which is why precautionary harvest control rules are needed.
4.3.14Species that have been overexploited may recover with cooperation between governments, the fishing industry, consumers and other interest groups, including NGOs, wholesale fishery markets and local supermarkets.HL
Atlantic bluefin tuna recovery, eastern Atlantic
Eastern Atlantic bluefin tuna were close to collapse by 2006 after catches of over 50,000 t a year ignored ICCAT's ~30,000 t limit. ICCAT's 15-year recovery plan from 2007 cut quotas and boat numbers, raised the minimum size from 10 kg to 30 kg and put observers on vessels over 15 m. From 2016 an electronic catch document tracked each fish to market, and in 2021 the IUCN moved the species from Endangered to Least Concern.
Shows recovery depending on cooperation: governments enforcing quotas, fishers accepting short seasons, markets refusing undocumented fish, and MSC labels and the Good Fish Guide informing consumers.
4.3.15According to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), coastal states have an exclusive economic zone stretching 370 km out to sea, within which the state's government can regulate fishing. Almost 60% of the ocean is the high seas outside these coastal zones, with limited intergovernmental regulation.HL
EU fishing access deals, Mauritania and Senegal
Under a deal applied from 2021, the EU pays Mauritania €57.5 million a year so its vessels can catch about 290,000 t of fish a year in Mauritania's EEZ. After the EU's Senegal deal ended in November 2024 over IUU fishing, European-run trawlers reflagged as Senegalese and kept fishing, while sardinella became scarce and expensive in local markets.
Demonstrates the equity and justice issue of selling EEZ access: governments and European consumers gain while local artisanal fishers lose catches and a cheap source of food.
PolicyHigh Seas Treaty (BBNJ Agreement)
The UN High Seas Treaty, adopted in June 2023, came into force on 17 January 2026 with 83 ratifications. It allows marine protected areas and environmental impact assessments beyond national jurisdiction, but it sets no fishing quotas, leaving fishing to bodies such as ICCAT.
Shows how international regulation of the high seas, where only about 1% is protected, is being strengthened, and where its limits on overfishing lie.
2023–26 Recovery, UNCLOS and Ethics
4.3.16Harvesting of seals, whales and dolphins raises ethical issues relating to the rights of animals and of indigenous groups of humans.HL
Grindadráp pilot whale hunt, Faroe Islands
The Faroese take about 600 long-finned pilot whales a year in the grindadráp, a hunt recorded since 1584. After 1,423 white-sided dolphins were killed at Skálafjørður on 14 September 2021, the government set a provisional limit of 500 a year. Animal welfare groups condemn the killing of whole family groups, and health authorities warn about mercury and PCBs in the meat.
Shows the clash between animal rights and a local cultural tradition defended as low-carbon food from an abundant species, which is not an Indigenous right.
Inuit narwhal hunting, Southeast Greenland
Inuit hunting of narwhal is permitted as aboriginal subsistence whaling under the IWC's 1986 moratorium. In Southeast Greenland, numbers may have fallen from over 1,700 to a few hundred since 1960, and NAMMCO advises stopping the hunt. Greenland has resisted a zero quota, citing hunters' knowledge, food security and Inuit culture.
Demonstrates the tension between Indigenous rights and conservation when the hunted population is in steep decline.
4.4.1Water pollution has multiple sources and has major impacts on marine and freshwater systems.
Lonza mercury contamination, Visp
The Lonza chemical plant at Visp, Valais discharged around 50 tonnes of mercury into a canal on the river Rhône between 1930 and 1976; the contamination was only discovered by chance in 2010 and clean-up continues today.
Shows how an identifiable point-source industrial effluent can persist in sediments and soil for decades, making pollution long-lasting and hard to remediate.
River Oder fish kill, Poland/Germany
The 2022 River Oder fish kill on the Poland–Germany border: salty waste water from upstream mines and industry, combined with low water levels and high summer temperatures, triggered a bloom of toxic golden alga (Prymnesium parvum) whose toxins attacked fish gills, killing around 250 tonnes of fish over hundreds of kilometres; the two nations ran a joint investigation, restricted salty discharges and set new salinity limits.
Demonstrates how a diffuse industrial pollution source interacts with climate conditions to cause a major freshwater impact and how transboundary management responds.
4.4.2Plastic debris is accumulating in marine environments. Management is needed to remove plastics from the supply chain and to clear up existing pollution.
Great Pacific Garbage Patch, North Pacific
The Great Pacific Garbage Patch in the North Pacific is the best-known accumulation of floating plastic trapped in the calm centre of one of the five great ocean gyres, where wind- and Earth-spin-driven currents concentrate debris that persists as plastic for decades.
Demonstrates how ocean gyre circulation concentrates persistent plastic debris, the mechanism behind marine plastic accumulation.
Great Pacific Garbage Patch, North Pacific Ocean Water Pollution and Water QualityMicroplastics in Lake Geneva
EPFL researchers towed a manta trawl across Lake Geneva and found microplastics in every beach sample, dominated by tiny polystyrene beads, at levels comparable to parts of the ocean, with the river Rhône carrying the plastic onward towards the Mediterranean.
Shows that plastic accumulation is not just marine: ~80% of ocean plastic originates on land, so lakes and rivers are the source of the problem.
Lake Geneva, Switzerland Water Pollution and Water Quality
4.4.5Eutrophication occurs when lakes, estuaries and coastal waters receive inputs of mineral nutrients, especially nitrates and phosphates, often causing excessive growth of phytoplankton.
Lake Geneva eutrophication
Lake Geneva's decline from the 1950s was driven by phosphate from washing powders, sewage and farm run-off, with total phosphorus peaking near 90 µg/L in 1979 (far above the healthy 10–15 µg/L target) and triggering thick blooms, because phosphate is the limiting nutrient in most fresh water.
Shows that adding the limiting nutrient (phosphate) from detergents, sewage and fertilisers causes the excessive phytoplankton growth described in the point.
4.4.6Eutrophication leads to a sequence of impacts and changes to the aquatic system.
Ulva green tide hydrogen sulphide, Brittany
Brittany's green tides show the eutrophication sequence on a coast: living *Ulva* seaweed is harmless, but when piled a metre thick on beaches it decomposes under a dry crust in airless conditions, and this rotting step releases poisonous hydrogen sulphide.
Shows the decomposition step of the impact sequence is where harm arises, not the growth of algae itself.
Brittany, France The lake that turned green
4.4.7Eutrophication can substantially impact ecosystem services.
Marées vertes (green tides), Brittany
Brittany's *marées vertes* (green tides): rivers carry nitrate (over 90% from agriculture, according to the French Court of Auditors) into shallow sandy Atlantic bays where *Ulva* sea lettuce grows a metre thick, then rots to release toxic hydrogen sulphide that has killed animals including a horse and been linked to human deaths, closing beaches and harming fisheries.
Quantifies how coastal eutrophication simultaneously damages fisheries, recreation, aesthetics and health services.
Brittany, France The lake that turned green
4.4.8Eutrophication can be addressed at three different levels of management.
Lake Geneva phosphorus recovery
Lake Geneva (Lac Léman), source of drinking water for over 600,000 people, was badly eutrophic after 1950s phosphate inputs pushed total phosphorus to a peak of ~90 µg/L in 1979; a Franco-Swiss commission (CIPEL, 1963) drove recovery via Switzerland's 1986 laundry-detergent phosphate ban, upgraded phosphorus-stripping sewage works and reduced farm phosphate, bringing total phosphorus down to 15.6 µg/L by the 2025 report with far fewer blooms.
Demonstrates all three management levels (change activity, reduce release, clean up) working together to reverse eutrophication, quantified by the fall from 90 to 15.6 µg/L.
4.4.9There is a wide range of pollutants that can be found in water.HL
PCBs in Lake Geneva char and trout
In 2008 Swiss and French authorities banned the sale of Lake Geneva char longer than 39 cm, and in 2015 lake trout longer than 54 cm, because larger, older fish held PCBs above WHO-recommended levels decades after PCB manufacture was banned.
Demonstrates persistence, bioaccumulation and biomagnification, since PCB content rose with fish size and top predators were affected while perch and pike were not.
TBT and dog whelk imposex, south coast of England
Tributyltin (TBT) antifouling paint caused imposex in female dog whelks, so whole populations vanished from parts of England's south coast in the 1980s–90s. After the IMO global ban came into force in 2008, seven of eleven sites between Poole and Selsey were recolonised by 2007–08, but sites near busy ports recovered least.
Shows how a dissolved endocrine-disrupting chemical harms wildlife at tiny concentrations and lingers in harbour mud, slowing recovery even after regulation.
4.4.10Algal blooms may produce toxins that threaten the health of humans and other animals.HL
Anatoxin-a dog deaths, Lake Neuchâtel
In July 2020 six dogs died within 24 hours of contact with floating mats of the cyanobacterium Microcoleus anatoxicus at the Areuse river mouth, Lake Neuchâtel. The mats contained the fast-acting neurotoxin anatoxin-a and grew on the delta bed rather than as a visible surface scum.
Shows a freshwater cyanotoxin directly killing animals, and that a harmful bloom can be invisible, which complicates public health warnings.
Karenia cristata bloom, South Australia
From March 2025 a Karenia dinoflagellate bloom, dominated by brevetoxin-producing K. cristata, affected over 30% of South Australia's coastline. It killed about one million marine animals, including more than 4,000 sharks and rays, and closed shellfish harvests, with oyster toxins taking up to 19 weeks to clear. It was triggered by a 10-month marine heatwave, upwelling and Murray flood nutrients.
Shows a marine dinoflagellate neurotoxin moving through shellfish and wildlife to threaten people, and links bloom severity to warming and stratification.
4.4.11The frequency of anoxic/hypoxic waters is likely to increase due to the combined effects of global warming, freshwater stratification, sewage disposal and eutrophication.HL
Baltic Sea hypoxia and dead zones
In 2024, 34% of the Baltic Proper sea bed was hypoxic and 18% was anoxic, compared with 1960–98 averages of 22% and 5%. Permanent freshwater stratification combines with farm and sewage nutrients and warming, and low-oxygen bottom water grew roughly tenfold to about 60,000 km² over 115 years.
Quantifies how stratification, sewage, eutrophication and warming combine to expand anoxic zones over time.
Lake Geneva deep-water oxygen deficit
Lake Geneva's phosphorus fell from almost 90 µg/L in 1979 to 15.6 µg/L, yet in spring 2025 its deepest water held only 2.7–3.2 mg/L oxygen, below the Swiss legal minimum of 4 mg/L. Warming has stopped the lake mixing fully since the winter of 2012.
Counter-example showing that cutting eutrophication alone does not prevent hypoxia when warming strengthens stratification.
4.4.12Sewage is treated to allow safe release of effluent by primary, secondary and tertiary water treatment stages.HL
Swiss micropollutant fourth stage, Villette, Geneva
In 2016 Switzerland became the first country to require selected sewage works to add a fourth treatment stage removing 80% of micropollutants using ozone or activated carbon. Geneva's Villette works (Thônex) switched on activated-carbon treatment in March 2024. By early 2025, 37 works served about 20% of the population, funded by a CHF 9 per resident annual levy.
Shows the limits of primary, secondary and tertiary treatment, which were designed for organic matter, nutrients and pathogens and let medicines and pesticides through.
Zermatt typhoid outbreak
In March 1963 typhoid broke out in Zermatt: 437 people fell ill and three died, most likely because sewage leaked into the tank where drinking water was chlorinated. At that time only about 14% of Swiss people were connected to sewage works, compared with 97% by 2005.
Demonstrates why sewage must be treated before release, linking untreated effluent directly to waterborne pathogens and disease.
4.4.14A biotic index can provide an indirect measure of water quality based on the tolerance to pollution, relative abundance and diversity of species in the community.HL
Oudar tributary IBCH survey, Versoix catchment
In 2015 the Canton of Geneva used the Swiss IBCH biotic index on the Oudar, which receives effluent from a French activated-sludge works near Versonnex. Invertebrates indicated good biological quality all year, yet diclofenac reached 121 ng/L, more than twice its 50 ng/L quality criterion.
Counter-example showing that biotic indices detect oxygen-depleting organic pollution but can miss micropollutants, so they need pairing with chemical tests.
StudyTrent Biotic Index, Trent basin
The Trent Biotic Index was devised in 1964 for rivers in England's Trent basin, scoring water 0–10 from the highest pollution-sensitive key group present (stoneflies down to sludge worms) and the total number of groups found.
Shows how a named biotic index combines tolerance and diversity into a single indirect measure of water quality.
4.4.15Overall water quality can be assessed by calculating a water quality index (WQI).HL
StudyNSF water quality index
The US National Sanitation Foundation WQI, developed in the 1970s with over 100 experts and used by Vernier, converts nine tests into Q-values and weights them, with dissolved oxygen (0.17) and faecal coliforms (0.16) weighted highest, to give a 0–100 score.
Demonstrates how a WQI is a weighted average whose weights reflect expert judgement, which also explains why a single score can hide one failing parameter.
