Foundation: real-world examples
Named cases you can use in an answer, each under the syllabus point it illustrates and linked to the lesson it comes from.
1 Foundation
1.1.1A perspective is how a particular situation is viewed and understood by an individual. It is based on a mix of personal and collective assumptions, values and beliefs.
McDonald's Suisse purchasing and Swiss beef
McDonald's Suisse reported 190 restaurants, 8,400 staff and over 85% of its CHF 250 million purchasing spent in Switzerland in 2025. Meanwhile Proviande data showed Swiss beef imports rose 22.6% and the Swiss share of beef supply fell from 81.8% to 77.4%: farmers, franchisees and welfare campaigners read the same figures in opposite ways.
Shows that people with identical evidence reach different positions because their assumptions and values differ, not because they lack facts.
1.1.2Perspectives are informed and justified by sociocultural norms, scientific understandings, laws, religion, economic conditions, local and global events, and lived experience, among other factors.
McDonald's dismantling, Millau, France
In August 1999, Confédération paysanne activists dismantled a McDonald's under construction in Millau, Aveyron, France, in protest at a trade dispute over hormone-treated beef and US tariffs on Roquefort. The action made the company a symbol of the European anti-globalisation movement.
Demonstrates how global events (trade disputes) and economic conditions for local farmers shape and justify a perspective strong enough to drive direct action.
1.1.4The values that underpin our perspectives can be seen in our communication and actions with the wider community. The values held by organizations can be seen through advertisements, media, policies and actions.
McLibel trial, England
In the McLibel case (1994–1997), McDonald's sued two campaigners in England over a critical leaflet. It became the longest trial in English legal history, and in 2005 the European Court of Human Rights ruled that the campaigners had been denied a fair trial.
Shows that an organisation's actions under pressure can reveal values (protecting its brand) that differ from those stated in its advertising.
1.1.6Worldviews are the lenses shared by groups of people through which they perceive, make sense of and act within their environment. They shape people’s values and perspectives through culture, philosophy, ideology, religion and politics.
Cultural burning and Amazonian agroforestry, Australia
Aboriginal Australians' traditional fire (cultural burning) management and indigenous Amazonian agroforestry view humans as part of nature with a responsibility to maintain ecological balance rather than to control resources.
Shows how culture and belief systems shape an environmental worldview in which humans are interdependent with, not separate from, nature.
Australia Environmental worldviewsSwiss Biodiversity Initiative
Switzerland's 2024 Biodiversity Initiative, backed by Pro Natura and BirdLife, would have set aside more land for habitats. It was rejected with 37.0% yes and carried only Basel-Stadt and Geneva. The Swiss Farmers' Union was the largest donor to a campaign against it that raised over CHF 2 million.
Demonstrates how group worldviews, such as farming interests that see land as productive versus conservation NGOs that value habitats, compete and shape collective environmental decisions.
1.1.7An environmental value system is a model that shows the inputs affecting our perspectives and the outputs resulting from our perspectives.
Geneva vs national Swiss environmental votes
In four federal environmental votes from 2021 to 2025, Geneva voted yes 11–15 percentage points more often than Switzerland as a whole. For example, it gave 51.2% yes to the 2024 Biodiversity Initiative against 37.0% nationally, and 74.5% yes to the 2023 Climate Act against 59.1% nationally.
Shows that the same proposals produce different outputs in different places because urban populations have different inputs to their environmental value systems, such as culture, education and media.
1.1.8Environmental perspectives (worldviews) can be classified into the broad categories of technocentric, anthropocentric and ecocentric.
Geoengineering schemes: sulfur injection and ocean fertilisation
Proposed stratospheric sulfur-aerosol injection and ocean iron fertilisation are geoengineering schemes intended to cool the planet and boost carbon absorption through large-scale technological intervention in the climate system.
Shows a technocentric worldview built on confidence that human ingenuity and engineering can solve environmental problems.
Whanganui River legal personhood, New Zealand
New Zealand granted legal personhood to the Whanganui River in 2017, giving the river its own legal rights and guardians, a policy that treats ecosystem health as intrinsically valuable rather than a resource for human use.
Demonstrates an ecocentric worldview by prioritising the rights of nature over economic growth or human expansion.
1.1.9Perspectives and the beliefs that underpin them change over time in all societies. They can be influenced by government or non-governmental organization (NGO) campaigns or through social and demographic change.
Swiss smoking prevalence trends
Swiss smoking (Swiss Health Survey, ~22,000 respondents): prevalence rose from 30% in 1992 to 33% in 1997, fell to 28% by 2007, plateaued at 27% through 2017 despite the 2010 passive smoking law and the 2011 SmokeFree government campaign, then dropped to 24% in 2022. An education gap also opened, with 20% of tertiary-educated people smoking compared with 25% of those without post-compulsory qualifications.
Shows that government laws and campaigns line up with changes in behaviour only loosely, and that campaigns may reach some social groups more than others.
Swiss tobacco advertising initiative
Public health organisations launched Switzerland's popular initiative on tobacco advertising, and the government opposed it. Voters passed it on 13 February 2022 with 56.6% of the vote, and it led to the Tobacco Products Act (in force October 2024).
Demonstrates an NGO campaign shifting public perspectives enough to override government opposition and turn changed values into law.
1.1.10The development of the environmental movement has been influenced by individuals, literature, the media, major environmental disasters, international agreements, new technologies and scientific discoveries.
Blue Planet II 'Blue Planet effect'
David Attenborough's Blue Planet II (BBC, 2017) showed ocean plastic to a mass audience, including an albatross feeding plastic to its chick. The surge in public concern that followed became known as the 'Blue Planet effect', although its size is disputed because some plastic policies were already under way.
Demonstrates media influence on public concern, and shows a critical point: it is hard to prove cause and effect when policy change had already started.
COP 27 loss and damage fund, Sharm el-Sheikh
COP 27 at Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt (November 2022) agreed to create a loss and damage fund for countries suffering climate impacts they did not cause, after developing countries had been refused for about thirty years. However, it did not strengthen the COP 21 Paris emissions commitments and left open who would pay into the fund.
Demonstrates how an international agreement can change what the movement is able to argue for, even though non-binding intergovernmental deals cannot force compliance.
Earthrise photograph and environmental movement
Bill Anders' Earthrise photograph, taken from Apollo 8 on Christmas Eve 1968, showed the whole Earth as small and finite with a thin atmosphere. It was carried worldwide by the media and fed into the first Earth Day (22 April 1970) and the 1972 Stockholm Conference, although it came six years after Silent Spring (1962).
Shows how the media can shape a movement by changing how people feel about the planet, and that this influence has to be qualified because it amplified a movement that already existed rather than starting it.
Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster
The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster (11 March 2011): a magnitude 9.0 earthquake shut the reactors down safely, but a 15–17 m tsunami about 50 minutes later overtopped the 5.7 m sea wall and disabled 12 of 13 backup generators, causing loss of cooling and hydrogen explosions. Around 164,000 people were displaced, and Germany shut eight reactors and accelerated its phase-out, Italy rejected a nuclear restart by referendum and Switzerland banned new reactors (a ban it is now reversing).
Shows how a major environmental disaster strengthened anti-nuclear sentiment and changed national energy policies, while the Swiss reversal shows the influence was uneven and temporary.
1.2.2A systems approach is a holistic way of visualizing a complex set of interactions, and it can be applied to ecological or societal situations.
Global carbon cycle as a stores-and-flows system
The global carbon cycle can be modelled as stores and flows: atmosphere ~800 GtC, terrestrial biosphere ~2,500 GtC, oceans ~38,000 GtC and fossil fuels ~10,000 GtC. These are linked by photosynthesis and respiration (~120 GtC/year each), ocean-atmosphere exchange (~90 GtC/year each way) and fossil fuel combustion (~9 GtC/year).
Shows how a holistic systems model puts numbers on stores and flows, so we can see that a small human flow can upset a large, balanced system.
Lac Léman as a system, Switzerland–France
Lac Léman can be modelled as a system. Its inputs are the Rhône at Le Bouveret, rain and treated sewage water carrying phosphate. Phytoplankton take up that phosphate, perch feed within the food web, and dead plankton sinks into the bed sediment. Outputs are the Rhône leaving at Geneva, evaporation and the city's drinking water abstraction.
Shows that a lake's behaviour comes from the interactions between its storages and flows, not from any single component. The case also shows how the boundary you draw decides what counts as an input or an output.
Lake Geneva (Lac Léman), Switzerland Systems and systems diagrams
1.2.4Flows are processes that may be either transfers or transformations.
Biosphere 2 oxygen decline, Arizona
Inside Biosphere 2 the crew lost about seven tonnes of oxygen, with levels falling from 21% to 14.2%, because excess soil compost was decomposed by microbes that consumed O₂ and released CO₂, which was then chemically transformed as it reacted into the concrete of the structure.
Shows a transformation (change of form) as decomposition converts organic carbon and O₂ into CO₂ which is then fixed into concrete, altering the system's atmospheric balance.
Biosphere 2, Oracle, Arizona, USA Systems and systems diagrams
1.2.5Systems can be open or closed.
Biosphere 2 closed system, Arizona
Biosphere 2, a three-acre sealed glass-and-steel structure in Arizona, housed eight people for two years (1991–1993) as a materially closed but energetically open system: no matter entered or left, but solar energy passed through, mirroring how Earth's biosphere operates.
Demonstrates the definition of a closed system as one that exchanges energy but not matter with its surroundings, at an engineered whole-system scale.
Biosphere 2 oxygen decline
Biosphere 2 in Oracle, Arizona, was a sealed 1.27 hectare glass structure where eight people lived from September 1991 to September 1993. It was materially closed but energetically open. Oxygen fell from about 20.9% to 14.2% over sixteen months because compost-rich soil sped up decomposition and the curing concrete absorbed the CO₂ released, so oxygen had to be pumped in.
Shows what a closed system means in practice: matter cannot cross the boundary while energy can, so any internal imbalance in the coupled oxygen and carbon cycles builds up instead of being exported.
Closed global hydrological cycle
The global hydrological cycle behaves as a closed system: solar energy enters and heat is radiated back to space, but the total mass of water stays essentially constant, simply cycling between oceans, atmosphere, ice caps and groundwater without meaningful exchange with space.
Contrasts a closed system (energy in/out, matter conserved) with an open drainage basin, clarifying the matter-versus-energy distinction at planetary scale.
Rhône basin water budget, Switzerland
The Rhône drainage basin above Geneva is an open system: water enters as precipitation and leaves as river discharge, evaporation and groundwater flow. Viewed globally, the same water sits inside a water cycle that is almost closed.
Demonstrates that whether a system is open or closed depends on where the boundary is drawn, not on what the system is made of.
Rhône basin, Switzerland The Earth as a system
1.2.6The Earth is a single integrated system encompassing the biosphere, the hydrosphere, the cryosphere, the geosphere, the atmosphere and the anthroposphere.
StudyGaia hypothesis (Lovelock and Margulis)
James Lovelock's Gaia hypothesis, developed further with Lynn Margulis, models the Earth as a single self-regulating system in which atmospheric composition and temperature are held within a range suited to life by feedback control mechanisms.
Shows the Earth treated as one integrated system, with the biosphere, atmosphere and other spheres coupled through feedback rather than working as separate systems.
1.2.7The concept of a system can be applied at a range of scales.
Rainforest bromeliad as a small system
A rainforest bromeliad holds a few litres of water in the cup between its leaves. Frogs breed in it, fallen insects decompose there and the plant absorbs the nutrients, so it forms a small system inside the larger rainforest system, which itself sits within global atmospheric circulation.
Demonstrates that storages, flows and boundaries apply at every scale, and that rainfall is an input to the bromeliad but only an internal flow at the global scale.
1.2.8Negative feedback loops occur when the output of a process inhibits or reverses the operation of the same process in such a way as to reduce change. They are stabilising as they counteract deviation.
Daisyworld model (Lovelock and Watson)
Lovelock and Watson's Daisyworld model shows black and white daisies self-regulating a planet's temperature: as the star warms, heat-absorbing black daisies decline and reflective white daisies spread, cooling the surface and holding global temperature near an optimum despite changing solar output.
Demonstrates how negative feedback from the biota maintains a planet in stable equilibrium, in contrast to a lifeless world.
Lynx and snowshoe hare cycle, Canada
The lynx and snowshoe hare population cycle in the boreal forests of Canada: when hares are abundant lynx numbers rise, increased predation crashes the hare population, lynx then starve and decline, allowing hares to recover. The result is regular oscillations around a long-term equilibrium.
Demonstrates how predator-prey negative feedback counteracts deviation to maintain a steady-state equilibrium over time.
Canada Feedback loops
1.2.9As an open system, an ecosystem will normally exist in a stable equilibrium, either in a steady-state equilibrium or in one developing over time (for example, succession), and will be maintained by stabilising negative feedback loops.
Grey wolf reintroduction, Yellowstone
The reintroduction of grey wolves to Yellowstone National Park in 1995 triggered a trophic cascade: wolves reduced elk browsing, allowing willows and aspen to recover, which stabilised riverbanks and changed river courses, shifting the ecosystem toward a new, more resilient equilibrium.
Shows how feedback following a species reintroduction can move a system into an alternative stable state.
Pre-industrial and modern carbon cycle
Before industrialisation, carbon inputs to the atmosphere (respiration, decomposition, volcanoes) roughly balanced outputs (photosynthesis, ocean uptake), and CO₂ stayed between 180 and 280 ppm. Now human emissions of about 11 GtC/year exceed natural sinks of about 6 GtC/year, and CO₂ has risen above 420 ppm.
Quantifies the contrast between a steady-state equilibrium and an open system whose inputs now exceed its outputs, so the atmospheric store keeps growing.
1.2.10Positive feedback loops occur when a disturbance leads to an amplification of that disturbance, destabilizing the system and driving it away from its equilibrium.
Arctic permafrost carbon feedback
Arctic permafrost holds about 1,400 GtC. Warming thaws it and releases stored methane and CO₂, which causes further warming and more thaw.
Demonstrates a self-amplifying positive feedback in the carbon cycle that moves the climate system away from equilibrium and could keep warming going even if emissions stop.
Arctic permafrost Carbon sinks, sources and human impactsForest removal and erosion feedback
Forest removal and erosion: clearing forest exposes soil to erosion that strips organic matter and nutrients, leaving fewer plants to anchor the soil, which in turn accelerates further erosion. This is a harmful, self-amplifying positive feedback that degrades the ecosystem.
Demonstrates a destabilising positive feedback driving a system away from equilibrium toward a degraded new state.
Ice-albedo feedback, Arctic Ocean
The ice-albedo feedback: as Arctic sea ice melts, dark ocean replaces reflective white ice, lowering albedo so more solar radiation is absorbed, which warms the region and melts still more ice. This amplifying loop can drive the climate towards a tipping point.
Shows positive feedback causing exponential deviation from equilibrium that can push the system past a tipping point into a new state.
Arctic Ocean Feedback loopsOcean warming and CO₂ solubility feedback
Rising atmospheric CO₂ warms the oceans. Warmer water dissolves less CO₂, so ocean uptake falls, more CO₂ stays in the atmosphere and warming increases further.
Demonstrates a positive feedback where the largest active carbon sink weakens as the disturbance grows, amplifying change rather than counteracting it.
1.2.11Positive feedback loops will tend to drive the system towards a tipping point.
Amazon rainforest dieback threshold
Amazon rainforest dieback: the Amazon generates much of its own rainfall through transpiration, so if deforestation passes a threshold, rainfall falls, the remaining forest dies back and releases stored carbon, and the system shifts to savanna, an alternative stable state that stores far less carbon.
Shows how a positive feedback (less forest, less rain, more dieback) drives an ecosystem past a tipping point into a regime shift to a new equilibrium.
Amazon rainforest, Brazil Carbon sinks, sources and human impacts
1.2.12Tipping points can exist within a system where a small alteration in one component can produce large overall changes, resulting in a shift in equilibrium.
Lake Erie eutrophication and bloom return
Phosphorus from farms and sewage caused algal blooms in western Lake Erie in the 1950s–60s. The 1972 Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement capped inputs at 11,000 tonnes a year and the lake recovered, but dissolved phosphorus from the Maumee River rose 218% between 1995 and 2011 and tipped it back into the bloom state. A record bloom followed in 2011, and in August 2014 microcystin left half a million Toledo customers unable to drink tap water for three days.
Shows how a small change in one input (the dissolved form of phosphorus) can flip a lake between alternative stable states, and that regime shifts can happen in both directions.
1.2.13A model is a simplified representation of reality; it can be used to understand how a system works and to predict how it will respond to change.
Biosphere 2 rainforest drought experiment
Now run by the University of Arizona, Biosphere 2 has been used to push a whole grown rainforest into a deliberate 70-day drought and measure how every tree responds, something impossible in a real forest.
Demonstrates that a simplified model can still be used to predict how a system responds to change, with its control over variables becoming a strength.
Biosphere 2, Oracle, Arizona, USA Models and their limitsGaia hypothesis, Lovelock
James Lovelock's Gaia hypothesis, named in 1965 with novelist William Golding, models Earth as a self-regulating system in which ocean algae emit gases that seed reflective clouds (keeping Earth ~10°C cooler) and made ten predictions that later came true.
Shows how a systems model can be used to make testable predictions about the outcome of events, such as biologically mediated temperature regulation.
1.2.14Simplification of a model involves approximation and, therefore, loss of accuracy.
Biosphere 2 model ecosystem, Arizona
Biosphere 2 in Arizona modelled rainforest, savannah, desert and coral reef ecosystems but left out wind (trees lacked stress wood and snapped), ultraviolet light (pollinating insects died out, so plants were hand-pollinated) and used young rich soils whose microbes consumed oxygen faster than plants replaced it.
Shows how specific simplifications in a lab-based model ecosystem caused it to diverge from the natural ecosystems it approximated.
Crawford Lake golden spike proposal, Ontario
The Anthropocene Working Group proposed sediment from Crawford Lake, Ontario (a meromictic lake ~270 m across and 23 m deep, with undisturbed annual layers recording a ~1950 plutonium spike from hydrogen-bomb tests) as the 'golden spike', but the International Commission on Stratigraphy rejected it in 2023 as too brief (under 70 years) to model in geologic time.
Demonstrates that models of a system have limitations: stratigraphic tools built for deep time struggle to represent recent, rapid human impact.
1.2.17Diversity and the size of storages within systems can contribute to their resilience and affect their speed of response to change (time lags).
Pacific Northwest old-growth forest carbon store
Pacific Northwest old-growth forests store 400–1,200 tonnes of carbon per hectare, and this large nutrient and biomass store is released slowly during drought years, allowing trees to survive months without rainfall.
Quantifies how a large storage creates a delayed, buffered output that sustains system function through periods of low input.
Pacific Northwest, USA System resiliencePacific Ocean thermal mass and ENSO lag
The Pacific Ocean's massive thermal mass takes decades to centuries for deep water temperatures to change significantly, so El Niño/La Niña cycles reveal a large time lag between climate forcing and ocean response, unlike small lakes that shift temperature rapidly with weather.
Demonstrates how a large storage introduces a long time lag between inputs and outputs, buffering the system against rapid change.
Pacific Ocean System resilience
1.2.18Humans can affect the resilience of systems through reducing these storages and diversity.
Amazon resilience loss study
Boulton, Lenton and Boers (Nature Climate Change, 2022) used satellite data on how quickly the forest recovered after droughts. They found that more than three quarters of the Amazon rainforest has lost resilience since the early 2000s, with the greatest loss near farmland and roads.
Gives evidence that deforestation and fragmentation reduce resilience by removing biomass storages and diversity, pushing the forest towards a tipping point.
1.3.1Sustainability is a measure of the extent to which practices allow for the long-term viability of a system. It is generally used to refer to the responsible maintenance of socio-ecological systems such that there is no diminishment of conditions for future generations.
Irish Potato Famine
The Irish Potato Famine (1845–1852) struck because a single potato variety, the Lumper, was grown across Ireland, so late blight wiped out the entire crop and caused mass starvation, whereas Peru's cultivation of over 3,000 potato varieties buffers against any single disease.
Shows how low genetic diversity destroys resilience while high diversity maintains a stable relationship between food inputs and outputs.
Lake Erie cyanobacterial bloom, USA
The 2014 Lake Erie cyanobacterial bloom, driven largely by agricultural phosphorus and nitrogen runoff, produced the toxin microcystin that shut off drinking water for around 500,000 people in Toledo, Ohio for three days.
Demonstrates how an imbalance between nutrient inputs and a system's outputs pushes eutrophication past a tipping point, undermining sustainability.
1.3.4Social sustainability focuses on creating the structures and systems, such as health, education, equity, community, that support human well-being.
Social impact of cod moratorium, Newfoundland
The 1992 cod moratorium put about 30,000 people out of work (around 12% of the provincial workforce). Newfoundland's population then fell by 10% in ten years, and outport communities with almost 500 years of fishing culture were hollowed out.
Demonstrates that environmental collapse undermines community, culture and well-being, which are the core of social sustainability.
1.3.5Economic sustainability focuses on creating the economic structures and systems to support production and consumption of goods and services that will support human needs into the future.
Economic impact of cod collapse, Newfoundland
After the cod collapse the Canadian government paid support until 1998, and one programme alone cost CAD 1.9 billion. The industry only survived by switching to shellfish, which made up CAD 383 million of the CAD 478 million in fish landings by 2007.
Shows that there is no economic sustainability without environmental sustainability: once the resource base failed, the economy had to be propped up and restructured.
1.3.7Unsustainable use of natural resources can lead to ecosystem collapse.
Northern cod collapse, Newfoundland
Factory freezer trawlers with echo sounders pushed the northern cod catch to a peak of 810,000 tonnes in 1968, and stock overestimates kept quotas too high. By 1992 the spawning stock was about 1% of its peak, and a moratorium was imposed on 2 July 1992. The collapse of capelin in 1991 helped hold the stock low in a regime shift, and it was not judged healthy until 2026.
Shows how harvesting faster than the replacement rate tipped an ecosystem into a new stable state that stopping fishing could not quickly reverse.
1.3.8Common indicators of economic development, such as gross domestic product (GDP), neglect the value of natural systems and may lead to unsustainable development.
Green GDP concept
GDP excludes environmental costs such as pollution and unpaid work, prompting the Green GDP concept that subtracts the value of environmental degradation from GDP so that a country with heavily polluting factories records a lower Green GDP.
Shows how conventional economic indicators fail to capture the poorly understood links between Earth systems and economic activity, requiring adjusted metrics.
1.3.9Environmental justice refers to the right of all people to live in a pollution-free environment, and to have equitable access to natural resources, regardless of issues such as race, gender, socio- economic status, nationality.
EU plastic waste dumping in Adana, Türkiye
After China's 2018 import ban, Türkiye became the top destination for EU plastic waste (503,000 t in 2025). In Adana, unrecyclable plastic is dumped or burnt in the open. Greenpeace found dioxins and heavy metals in soil, and Human Rights Watch (2022) recorded breathing and skin problems among child, refugee and migrant workers.
Demonstrates global injustice by nationality and socio-economic status: rich countries export pollution to marginalised workers with little power to complain.
KlimaSeniorinnen v Switzerland
In the 2022 Swiss heatwave 623 people died, nearly 90% over 65 and older women at highest risk. The KlimaSeniorinnen (2,500+ women aged 64+) took Switzerland to the European Court of Human Rights, which ruled on 9 April 2024 that inadequate emissions cuts and no carbon budget violated their rights.
Shows environmental injustice by age, gender and income within a rich country, and how a legal right to a safe environment can be asserted.
1.3.11Sustainability and environmental justice can be applied at the individual to the global operating scale.
Swiss parliament rejects KlimaSeniorinnen ruling
After the KlimaSeniorinnen community group won at the European Court of Human Rights in 2024, the Swiss parliament voted in June 2024 to reject the ruling, and the Council of Europe said in 2025 that Switzerland's response was still not enough.
Shows that action at the community and international scale can be blocked at the country scale.
1.3.12Sustainability indicators include quantitative measures of biodiversity, pollution, human population, climate change, material and carbon footprints, and others. These indicators can be applied on a range of scales, from local to global.
Geneva official chestnut tree record
Since 1818 the sautier of Geneva has recorded the first-leaf date of the canton's official horse chestnut tree. The date has moved from April towards February, with a clear shift after the 1950s and a record early date of 29 December 2002. However, four different trees have been used over that period.
Shows how a single named local indicator, measured consistently over two centuries, can track climate change, while the changes of tree show why a consistent method matters.
1.3.13The concept of ecological footprints can be used to measure sustainability. If these footprints are greater than the area or resources available to the population, this indicates unsustainability.
Almond water footprint, Central Valley
California's Central Valley almond groves are flood-irrigated several times each season, giving high water footprints of ~1 gallon per almond, ~5 gallons per walnut, ~14 per orange and up to 60 gallons per avocado, in a state where ~80% of US water use goes to agriculture.
Shows how the land and water required to supply a population's food is measurable and location-specific, a core component of the ecological footprint.
Central Valley, California, USA Measuring sustainabilityAmsterdam Doughnut Economics adoption
Amsterdam became the first city to downscale the Doughnut Economics model in 2020 (with Circle Economy), adopting it to guide its ambition of becoming a fully circular city by 2050 and to account for its overseas impacts, such as on garment workers in Bangladesh.
Shows a more-developed city acting to bring its consumption back within planetary boundaries, as required of high-income nations with the greatest obligation to transform.
BLT sandwich carbon footprint
A single BLT sandwich carries an embedded footprint of ~800 g CO₂ equivalent, dominated by the fertiliser for the bread and especially the four strips of bacon, so eating one daily for a year equals the emissions of driving a car from New York to Chicago.
Demonstrates how the resources and waste absorption behind everyday consumption accumulate, making an ecological footprint concrete at the individual scale.
Regenerate Costa Rica initiative
Costa Rica launched the 'Regenerate Costa Rica' initiative using the Doughnut Economics framework, aiming to become one of the world's first regenerative nations.
Shows a national-scale attempt to redesign the economy to operate within Earth-system capacity through regenerative and distributive design.
Costa Rica Models and their limits
1.3.14The carbon footprint measures the amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) produced, measured in carbon dioxide equivalents (in tonnes). The water footprint measures water use (in cubic metres per year).
StatisticPer-capita CO2 emissions by country
Per-capita CO₂ production emissions vary starkly: the USA emits ~16.1 tonnes per person per year, China ~7.1 tonnes, the UK ~5.5 tonnes, the DR Congo only ~0.03 tonnes, and oil-and-gas-rich Qatar ~38.6 tonnes.
Quantifies how unevenly humanity draws down the atmosphere's carbon-absorbing capacity, showing that climate debt is driven overwhelmingly by wealthy, high-consumption nations.
1.3.15Biocapacity is the capacity of a given biologically productive area to generate an ongoing supply of renewable resources and to absorb its resulting wastes.
Ecological footprint and overshoot
The ecological footprint, measured in global hectares per person, reveals ecological overshoot when a region's footprint exceeds its available biocapacity, meaning resources are consumed faster than ecosystems can regenerate them.
Quantifies how Earth's finite biocapacity imposes measurable limits on resource use and flags unsustainable consumption.
Switzerland ecological deficit
In 2025 the average Swiss resident had an ecological footprint of 3.9 gha, against only 1.1 gha of Swiss biocapacity per person and 1.48 gha of world biocapacity per person. Swiss biocapacity covers just 26% of the footprint, so Switzerland's Country Deficit Day falls on 4 April and its Overshoot Day on 11 May.
Quantifies unsustainability by comparing a footprint with both national and global biocapacity, showing an ecological debtor that covers its deficit through imports.
1.3.16Citizen science plays a role in monitoring Earth systems and whether resources are being used sustainably.
Swiss Phenology Network, MeteoSwiss
MeteoSwiss has run the Swiss Phenology Network since 1951. Volunteers at about 160 stations record leaf opening and flowering dates for 26 plant species. A 2018 study noted the network's drawbacks: imprecise observations, unevenly spread stations and interrupted records.
Demonstrates how volunteers give cheap, nationwide, decades-long data for climate research, and also shows the reliability limits of citizen science.
1.3.17There are a range of frameworks and models that support our understanding of sustainability, each with uses and limitations.
Doughnut Economics model
Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics model (first published 2012) frames a 'safe and just space for humanity' between a social foundation (based on the social SDGs) and an ecological ceiling (based on the nine planetary boundaries), redefining sustainability as thriving in balance rather than endless GDP growth.
Demonstrates an alternative interpretation of sustainability that integrates both social justice and ecological limits, contrasting with growth-based definitions.
Greater Geneva doughnut limitations
The Greater Geneva doughnut shows the limits of sustainability models: 6 of its 14 indicators had no data, its footprint figures relied on data from around 2011 that probably understate the real values, and by early 2024 it had drawn little interest from local businesses or residents.
Demonstrates that models simplify reality and depend on data and public uptake, which gives concrete evidence for evaluating their limitations.
Planetary Health Check, Potsdam
The 2025 Planetary Health Check by the Potsdam Institute's Planetary Boundary Science Lab reported that seven of the nine planetary boundaries have now been breached, with ocean acidification the latest as surface ocean pH has fallen ~0.1 units (a 30–40% rise in acidity) since the industrial era.
Provides a science-based interpretation of sustainability as staying within quantified Earth-system limits, and quantifies the extent of overshoot.
1.3.18The UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a set of social and environmental goals and targets to guide action on sustainability and environmental justice.
UN Sustainable Development Goals halfway point
In 2015 UN member states adopted the 2030 Agenda's 17 Sustainable Development Goals with 169 targets; at the 2023 halfway point only 15% of targets were on track and over a third had stagnated or regressed, with more than 780 million people facing chronic hunger.
Demonstrates the SDG framework as a concrete global sustainability agenda while quantifying its limited progress against both social foundation and planetary-boundary targets.
2015–2023 Development, justice and the SDGs
1.3.19The planetary boundaries model describes the nine processes and systems that have regulated the stability and resilience of the Earth system in the Holocene epoch. The model also identifies the limits of human disturbance to those systems, and proposes that crossing those limits increases the risk of abrupt and irreversible changes to Earth systems.
IKEA and WWF acacia timber sourcing
IKEA, in partnership with WWF, sources acacia timber from FSC-certified plantations grown with smallholder farmers to allow forest regeneration and support local communities.
Illustrates operating within the land-system-change and biosphere-integrity boundaries by managing a renewable resource at its replacement rate.
1.3.20The doughnut economics model is a framework for creating a regenerative and distributive economy in order to meet the needs of all people within the means of the planet.
Greater Geneva doughnut model and charter
In 2022 University of Lausanne researchers drew a doughnut for Greater Geneva (about one million people across Switzerland and France) using 14 indicators with 2050 targets. It showed overshoot, such as a carbon footprint of 11 t CO₂e per person against a target of net zero, alongside shortfall, with more than 14.4% of people living in precarity. In January 2023 local politicians signed the Grand Genève en Transition charter, which sets 10 ecological and social objectives for 2050.
Shows the doughnut being scaled down from global to city-region level, measuring the ecological ceiling and social foundation together and leading to real policy commitments.
MUD Jeans leasing model, Amsterdam
MUD Jeans in Amsterdam leases jeans rather than selling them, returning worn pairs to be shredded and remanufactured into new denim in Prato, Italy; the EU circular-economy package projected 2 million new jobs and €600 billion in business savings.
Shows how the doughnut model's economic redesign can decouple prosperity from resource depletion while staying within planetary limits and meeting social needs.
Amsterdam, Netherlands Sustainability, its pillars and collapseSouth Africa 1996 Constitution and NEMA
South Africa's 1996 Constitution was the first in the world to explicitly recognise the right to a healthy environment as a basic human right, implemented via the National Environmental Management Act (NEMA), which mandates public participation and environmental impact assessments before development is approved.
Demonstrates how legal structures deliver social-foundation goals such as equity, health and political voice by empowering communities to hold polluters accountable.
1.3.21The circular economy is a model that promotes decoupling economic activity from the consumption of finite resources. It has three principles: eliminating waste and pollution, circulating products and materials, and regenerating nature.
Freitag circular economy bags, Zurich
Freitag, a company in Zurich, makes bags from used lorry tarpaulins, seat belts and bicycle inner tubes. It keeps products in use through free repair parts, rental, exchange and resale, and launched a single-plastic recyclable backpack in 2024. However, its tarpaulin bags still cannot be recycled as a whole at the end of their life.
Shows the circular economy principles of eliminating waste and circulating materials in practice, and also exposes the technical limits on closing the loop.
